Tarter’s Insurance Agency

Insurance Made Easy

Tarter’s Insurance Agency is located in Crawfordsville, Indiana and serves the greater Montgomery County area. We are independently owned and operated.

An independent agency is not about the insurance company, it’s about the customer. It provides the opportunity to stay with your agent permanently and have the flexibility to switch insurance carriers to meet your changing needs.

Types of Insurance we provide:

Insurance made easy.

  • We’ll handle the transfer of coverage from your existing carrier.
  • We’ll handle SR22 and SR50 directly with the BMV, if necessary.
  • We’ll get your claims started instead of a 1-800 number.
  • We’ll educate you and not just sell you a product.

We’re not a computer or simply a picture.

At Tarter’s Insurance, you will have a live, face-to-face meeting with your actual agent.

Feel free to give us a call at 765-362-5552 or complete the form below and we’ll contact you. If you would rather compare rates first, use the quote button on the right.


Auto Insurance Quotes and Home Insurance Quotes Powered by AgentInsureAuto Insurance Quotes and Home Insurance Quotes Powered by AgentInsure